Is Brees great, or is it Payton?

I agree he’s great but I think NO shows that it takes a complete team to consistently win. When good teams lose their QB they often keep winning when average teams lose their QB the team usually folds like GB has.

The only correct answer is the same as it would be for Brady/Belichick - Both are great.

Brees was great at Purdue, and when he played for the Chargers.


Brees was dominating long before a guy named Kamara came to town. Brees is in the GOAT conversation, Bridgewater has had a nice few games. The gulf is wide and that with full understanding that Payton is a great playcaller that ruined our 2011 season with max protect and chipping Avril with his backs and TE’s.

1 Like